“Yes, that makes sense”

ELIZABETH NELSON:
Warning: this episode includes description of suicide and may be upsetting to some listeners.

Welcome to Episode 21 of Hollow Hype. In Episode 20, Heidi was convicted of financial crimes in California just a few years after she left University of Michigan in Ann Arbor. Heidi was convicted of financial crimes in West Virginia just a few years before she returned to Ann Arbor.

Ten years ago, Heidi landed on what looked like the perfect business.

[2018 News Report]

ROD MALONI:
Out here at the University of Michigan it's been a good season all the way around but Airbnb will tell you for them it's been an exceptionally good season with the Wolverines. Ann Arbor is that property owners dream college town listed as one of the nation's top places to live, a top five football team in the biggest stadium of the game that fills all the local hotels to the brim. Then along comes Airbnb, the side hustle where you rent your home to strangers.

Airbnb says they've got about 10% better this year than last year and their expectation is they'll do even better next year.

[MUSIC]

ELIZABETH NELSON:
My name is Elizabeth Nelson. From 2018 to 2022, I served on Ann Arbor City Council. That experience taught me a lot. Mostly, I learned: people will say just about anything if they think you’ll believe it. This is HOLLOW HYPE.

Six years ago, Heidi projected confidence about her Airbnb complex on Henry Street and other businesses.

In March 2020, right before the COVID shutdown, Heidi presented at a conference for startups. She had 60 seconds to pitch her business to potential investors.

[2020 Recording]

HOST:
4M, you go next.

HEIDI:
Hi I'm Heidi Poscher I'm with 4M. 4M is a Tier 2 market co-living, co-working, shared mobility campus. We market directly to businesses. If you take a look at Tier 1 markets the costs and constraints are just far too high to be able to effectively share, use the share economy to lower big-ticket items that relate to space. But 4M has leapfrogged those issues. We've created a Tier 2 market campus where we can offer a cost model of 50% reduction in terms of the overall cost. Our spaces are beautiful and they're spacious. We're fully wired, we offer mobility at a sip. But the most important thing that 4M does is that it offers a collective environment where teams can really focus on teamwork. We focus on and emphasize collaboration team-building problem-solving. So when team members leave 4M, whether they're going to remote location or corporate headquarters, they're fully prepared to

[GONG]

HOST:
[laughter] First one. We had to get one. Thank you so much for that.

ELIZABETH NELSON:
I never imagined that this podcast would attract so many listeners. Thousands of people are now working their way through every episode. Over a third of them live outside of Michigan. Hollow Hype has now been downloaded in every state, except for Montana. So if you know anyone in Montana…

Listeners have reached out to me with questions. Moving forward, I’m going to answer a few every week. One listener asked:

Is Heidi listening, is there any way to know? Have you received any personal backlash or feedback? I’m wondering how this investigation is being received.

My answer is: I have no idea if Heidi is listening. People who know her have speculated that she might be, but I don’t actually know. I’ve not spoken to her since that weird phone call when she offered me “I don’t mean a bribe.” Last month, my friend Ralph and I attended a bankruptcy hearing for Southtown. We saw Heidi, but we didn’t talk.

The feedback I’ve gotten from others has been overwhelmingly positive. This story has opened the eyes of a lot of Ann Arbor residents who simply didn’t realize what had happened. I’ve made new friends. If you appreciate this podcast, please give it a rating and a review on whatever platform you use to listen to it.

Another question this week:

What happened to the local architect who was working with Heidi? They seemed tight and chummy and she disappeared?

Architect Lisa Sauve resigned from the City Planning Commission and moved to Detroit. Heidi still owes Lisa’s firm, Synechdoche, hundreds of thousands of dollars for their work on Southtown. Lisa’s advocacy to rezone that block increased its value by millions, but Heidi refuses to pay her. If the Southtown bankruptcy is resolved under the current plan, there would be plenty of money available to pay Synechdoche’s fees. Still, Heidi is disputing the bill instead of allowing Lisa to join the list of creditors.

Another question:

Why are people so afraid of a felon? She’s obviously a con woman? Do you think people are just embarrassed?

A lot of people are embarrassed. Reputable people worked with Heidi. They were hired to help promote her businesses. It was just a job, but in retrospect it’s a job they wish they hadn’t accepted.

A few people are afraid of Heidi but many more people are afraid of Heidi’s friends. The local network that supported Heidi still exists. Some remain loyal. Politically, the story of Heidi is explosive. It discredits people in power and the ideas they’ve promoted to the community.

[MUSIC]

For years, elected leaders and their biggest donors argued that the City should step back and let developers, like Heidi, build whatever investors were willing to fund. The free market would provide what’s best for Ann Arbor and skeptics should just get out of the way. A unanimous City government insisted that developers like Heidi suffer from too much oversight and public scrutiny. City leaders crafted policy consistent with this approach and framed it with words like efficiency and streamlining.

Ann Arbor is not alone. Corporate interests have marketed the same message across the country, in many other profitable housing markets. Some residents have swallowed the idea under the generous sounding banner of “Neighbors for More Neighbors.” Truth in advertising would probably be “neighbors for more investors.”

Powerful people in Ann Arbor are afraid of losing control of the message.

Heidi is an inconvenient example of what can go wrong. Public scrutiny is important. It turns out that some level of skepticism is actually a good thing.

I hope that in telling this story, more people can see how easily local governments can be manipulated, and how vulnerable we are to someone like Heidi when no one can push back or ask questions.

In the fall of 2025, Heidi and Marge’s 4M businesses were on the verge of collapse. Heidi had exaggerated the cost and value of the properties they owned, in order to borrow more and more money against them. Heidi and Marge struggled to keep up with the payments on all these debts.

On October 8, 2025, Heidi and Marge confirmed an additional $20 million loan.

Two days later, Marge Poscher was found dead at 809 Henry Street.

[MUSIC]

[2024 court recording]

BRUCE LAIDLAW:
You can't as an attorney assist a client to um engage in illegal activity. Using these funds for purposes other than affordable housing is illegal.

ELIZABETH NELSON:
That’s my friend, Bruce, arguing before a local judge in 2024. Bruce served as an Attorney for the City of Ann Arbor for over twenty years. After his career with the city, he worked as general counsel for five other local municipalities. Over the course of his career, he drafted hundreds of ordinances and charter amendments. He represented plaintiffs with Freedom of Information Act requests. Bruce helped plaintiffs challenge violations of the Open Meetings Act.

Bruce is retired but he continues to pay close attention to what’s happening in Ann Arbor. He noticed when the city used money that was supposed to fund affordable housing to buy an election center from a campaign donor. He noticed when the block of Southtown was rezoned twice for Heidi. When he learned about Marge’s death, Bruce started filing his own Freedom of Information Act requests.

We know a lot more about what happened that night because Bruce filed those requests. He shared all the documents and recordings with me and we’ve talked extensively about them. Bruce and I have different theories about what might have happened. We’ve argued about what conclusions might be drawn from the evidence. One point we agree on: bodycam footage, police reports, and Heidi’s own statements do not add up.

[Sound effect, car running]

Heidi told police that on the morning of October 10th, she drove to Cleveland for a business appointment. She said she left Ann Arbor at 10 a.m. for a meeting at noon. Heidi’s destination was likely west of Cleveland if she was able to reach it in two hours.

Heidi told police that she last spoke to Marge on the phone at noon. She left her meeting at about 2 p.m. and tried to call Marge several times but could not reach her. Almost three hours later, at 4:53 p.m., Heidi called Chelsey, an employee at Venue. She asked Chelsey to check on Marge at the Henry street home. Heidi told police that she made this phone call because she knew Chelsey would be close by.

[Sound effect, car running]

Heidi estimated that when she made this call, she would have been about an hour away from Ann Arbor, just crossing back into Michigan. The Michigan-Ohio border could be as close as 45 minutes, but this was a Friday around 5 p.m. There would have been traffic.

[Sound effect, outdoors]

Venue is just a few blocks from 809 Henry street, a four minute walk.

[Sound effect, key code]

Chelsey had a code to enter the front door of 809 Henry street, but she found the bedroom door locked. After getting assistance to open this locked door, Chelsea eventually found Marge on the bed with a plastic bag over her head. She called 911. Ann Arbor police were dispatched to the house at 5:03 p.m.

[2025 recording, 911 call]

OPERATOR:
[unintelligible] on the phone with our paramedic dispatch, stay on the line don’t hang up, I’ll talk to them first

[phone ring]

ELIZABETH NELSON:
In that 911 call, Chelsey can be heard sobbing, as she performed CPR for seven minutes, waiting for police to arrive. It must have felt like an eternity.

Police arrived at 5:10. In bodycam footage, Heidi is sitting in the living room just five minutes later, at 5:15.

As police and EMT crowded the bedroom, they struggled to track the evidence on the scene

[2025 Bodycam Recording]

OFFICER:
Where’s that bag? The one that was on her head?

ELIZABETH NELSON:
Officers drew conclusions almost immediately.

[2025 Bodycam Recording]

OFFICER 1:
Anyone else have any other ideas?

OFFICER 2:
The bag over the head is pretty…

OFFICER 3:
I think we’re giving her what she wants, we’re just delaying it by…

OFFICER 4:
Actually, her note was..

OFFICER 5:
The… yeah, the most detailed I’ve ever seen and the entire folder…

OFFICER 4:
Yeah, it’s very detailed actually

ELIZABETH NELSON:
They confirmed information based on interviews with Chelsey and Heidi

[2025 Bodycam Recording]

OFFICER 1:
What time was the last time they saw her?

OFFICER 2:
Noon

OFFICER 3:
Noon

OFFICER 1:
Noon?

OFFICER 1:
They did not witness it, right?

OFFICER 2:
No.

OFFICER 3:
No

ELIZABETH NELSON:
Chelsey last saw Marge at noon, at Venue.

Before she was even declared dead, at least one officer on the scene announced to five colleagues that he would rather not even investigate a situation like this.

[2025 Bodycam Recording]

OFFICER:
She made this choice. Unfortunately, by law and by other things we have to be here with this, okay? If it was my way, I walked in here, I saw that note, I’d make a phone call. Unfortunately we can’t just do that. (unintelligible]

ELIZABETH NELSON:
At 6 p.m, another officer, calling for backup, described a fairly limited investigation

[2025 Bodycam Recording]

OFFICER:
You’ll most likely need some evidence collection bags for a note and also a plastic bag.

[MUSIC]

ELIZABETH NELSON:
Written police reports name every person on the scene except for one: former Ann Arbor City Council Member and self-described “philanthropist” Linh Song. Before the police left, Heidi called Linh and asked her to come over. Officers would have recognized Linh as one of the most influential people in town, a benefactor to political leaders all the way up to the state and national level.

At 8 p.m., police were still on the scene at Henry Street when Ann Arbor City Administrator Milton Dohoney sent a text message to every member of City Council. Dohoney’s message explained, in part:

Be advised that Margaret Elizabeth Poscher of 4M development company was found dead a while ago. We believe that it was a suicide. While there are compelling indicators, there are more investigative steps that must be taken. How this comes out publicly may be dependent on family wishes. I will not be giving any more updates about this unless things change and we believe it is not a suicide. That is not likely but we have to run it to ground. I know that many of you knew her. I am sorry to bring you this news.

In response to that message, Council Member Jen Eyer replied

Oh my god no, I was just talking to Heidi this morning.

Council Member Lisa Disch replied

I want to send her a note but that seems also inappropriate.

At noon the following day, October 11th, Dohoney sent another text message to every member of City Council:

FINAL UPDATE: Be advised that in a follow-up meeting with members of the family today, they made a specific demand that no member of city government make social media or otherwise public comments about Margaret or her passing. I can say that this is not an unusual request. We were given it in a demand statement, so I am informing you. Thanks

Council Member Lisa Disch replied,

Yes, that makes sense.

Does it? Does it make sense?

In the four years I served on City Council, I never got updates like this, about an event that occurred in a private home. I can think of only one message I ever received about an active police investigation: I was notified about a possible shooting on the University campus. All of City Council was alerted immediately, because if it was a shooting, there might be lockdowns and major city disruptions. That’s the only time I ever got a text message about a police investigation.

Why would City Council be notified about what happened to Marge, in this way, with this explanation? Why are city leaders accepting a “demand statement” from any private citizen, when there’s an active police investigation? Did the police ever talk to City Council about their friends, Heidi and Marge?

None of this is in any police report.

Bodycam footage from the evening of October 10th is heavily redacted. For much of it, the visual is obscured, the audio is silenced, or both are unavailable.

Local media did not report on Marge Poscher’s death. On October 14th, I heard about Marge and contacted Ann Arbor News reporter Ryan Stanton. He replied to me “That’s sad.” There was no article.

On October 16th, the county medical examiner signed an initial death certificate for Marge Poscher. Under surviving spouse, Heidi is listed by a name she has not used for decades: Heidi Caroline Ditchendorf. This initial report describes the manner of death as “Pending investigation.” The time of death is listed as 5:39 p.m., October 10th.

[MUSIC]

Weeks later, Crain’s Detroit got a tip and followed up.

On November 6, Kirk Pinho of Crain’s Detroit sent an email to Brett Lenart, in the Ann Arbor building department. Pinho asked about the status of Southtown, considering Marge’s death. Lenart reported that there had been a recent project meeting with the 4M team to discuss alternative site ideas. It seemed to be moving forward.

When Pinho contacted the Ann Arbor police department, communications manager Chris Page replied that there was an active death investigation but no foul play was suspected. An article about Marge was published in Crain’s Detroit on November 13, over a month after her death.

The day after Crain’s published, MLive posted a story about Marge. They included quotes from Heidi, who praised Marge for “creating connections with people. She was so empathetic. Marge was a caretaker at heart, and people just loved her.”

On November 24th, staff in the Ann Arbor police department planned a meeting between Heidi and the chief of police. An email explained:

Ms. Poscher’s wife commit [sic] suicide recently. We put out a statement to Mlive indicating that there was an investigation into the incident, but that no foul play is suspected. Mlive then reached out to Ms. Poscher and asked her a number of questions. Ms. Poscher was upset by this and the Chief has offered to meet with her to discuss it.

On December 10, the police department responded to an email from MLive and explained that the investigation was closed. The medical examiner had determined there was no foul play.

The following day, an amendment to Marge’s death certificate was filed with the County. It listed a new manner of death: “suicide.”

There’s a reason Heidi may have been concerned about publicity around Marge’s death.
Heidi was still working to arrange loans. These loans depended on Marge’s identity as the borrower. When 4M or Southtown needed money, it was Marge’s Personal Financial Statement that was submitted to potential lenders. Weeks after she died, Heidi attempted to move forward with loans that featured Marge as the borrower, using Marge’s personal financial statement. Heidi continued to engage with lenders as if Marge was still alive.

I’ve talked to people who did business with Heidi. More than one person has shared instances of Heidi forging documents to facilitate a deal. In one case, Heidi actually admitted it, as if forging documents was nothing out of the ordinary.

[MUSIC]

The investigation into Marge’s death feels incomplete. Police on the scene were ready to draw conclusions almost immediately. Officers remarked that they had never seen a suicide note so detailed and specific. It was remarkable, and yet they didn’t question it.

Heidi presented a timeline of her own whereabouts that does not make sense. She says that she went to a meeting in Cleveland, and allowed herself two hours to get there. Heidi told police that she left that meeting at 2 p.m. Almost three hours later, she made a phone call to Chelsey. Heidi told police that she was an hour away from Ann Arbor when she made that phone call. Bodycam footage from that night shows that Heidi arrived at the house on Henry Street just twenty minutes later, five minutes after the police arrived.

Where was Heidi that day? Was she two hours away? Three hours away? How did she get to Henry Street so quickly? Why did Heidi call Chelsey when she was only twenty minutes away from home?

Thanks for listening. Visit HollowHype.com to find more information about this episode.

Coming up in episode 22: more of what police found at Henry Street, what they accepted and what they didn’t question.

If you have something to share about Heidi’s activities in Michigan, Ohio, West Virginia, or California or you have questions you’d like answered in a future episode, please reach out to hollowhypepodcast@gmail.com

“Yes, that makes sense”
Broadcast by