“Where was she at?”

ELIZABETH NELSON:
Warning: this episode includes description of suicide and may be upsetting to some listeners.

Welcome to Episode 22 of Hollow Hype. In Episode 21, less than 24 hours after the death of Marge, Heidi demanded that City leaders make no public comment about it. Six weeks after Marge’s death, Heidi met with the Ann Arbor police chief because she was upset about information that had been shared with local media.

Heidi was not always so anxious about media coverage. Before rumors spread about her criminal record, before the businesses were transferred into Marge’s name, and before the Michigan Daily published the article about her felony convictions, Heidi regularly presented herself as the founder and owner of the 4M businesses.

[2020 recording]

HEIDI:
I want you to know a few things about our team. What I want you to know is that our team has broad expertise, in real estate, in telecom, in energy and renewable energy, in transportation and in digital services. and all of these broad areas of expertise really influenced how we designed and built 4M.

When we do make investment decisions we try to balance our new business models with creating some form of common good.

ELIZABETH NELSON:
The Airbnbs on Henry street are now in receivership, due to unpaid debts. There is no longer any pretense about how they might be used by young professionals. The units are advertised as hotel suites, with an emphasis on their proximity to the Stadium and how they can host large groups and families.

This is how Heidi promoted the Henry Street project back in 2020.

[2020 recording]

HEIDI:
Our cost model is 45 percent lower than typical costs. Our structure allows people to
make individual impacts in terms of environmental sustainability, reducing gridlock, energy consumption, pollution and that type of thing. But most importantly I think is that our modular approach allows for us to create benefits that bring new innovation into the community.

We've got a lot to offer and the people on this call work and know people that can
take this from being a cool concept to a really amazing facility. So we invite you to spread the word and really reach out and let people know that we’re interested in answering questions.

In fact, we're actually working with SPARK and with Detroit Regional Partnership to tailor programs specifically for them.

ELIZABETH NELSON:
My name is Elizabeth Nelson. From 2018 to 2022, I served on Ann Arbor City Council. That experience taught me a lot. Mostly, I learned: people will say just about anything if they think you’ll believe it. This is HOLLOW HYPE.

Thank you to everyone who has sent me questions. I’m happy to answer what I can. A listener emailed me:

What’s the occupancy percentage for the Henry on and off football season?

That’s a good question. The short answer is that I don’t really know, but Heidi almost certainly exaggerated its occupancy rate when she needed to borrow money. The property now has $20 million in debt attached to it. Heidi was able to borrow that much by convincing lenders that it generated significant annual revenue. A credible source told me that this revenue was not real, that the property may actually be losing money. At this point, the Henry is likely to be sold to cover debts, but the property is probably upside down in terms of value.

Another question:

Has Heidi's meeting in Cleveland been confirmed? With whom did she meet? When did she arrive and when did she leave?

Confirmation of this meeting happened six days after Marge’s death, when Ann Arbor Police Detective Luick phoned Heidi. Detective Luick described that phone call in a written report:

[Sound effect- computer typing]

I asked HEIDI who was at the meeting with her and she stated several developers, and she provided the names of GARETH VAUGHN and MARK CONZELMANN as being attendees. HEIDI provided phone numbers for GARETH and MARK.

I called GARETH directly after my phone conversation with HEIDI. GARETH answered and I confirmed with him that he attended the meeting with HEIDI in Cleveland. GARETH stated the meeting was over at about 2:00 PM.

[MUSIC]

There is no indication that the detective confirmed any other details about that Cleveland meeting. The two people that Heidi identified are developers: Gareth Vaughn is with the Higley Company and Mark Conzelmann is with Newbrook Partners. Both businesses are based in Cleveland.

A few weeks after Marge’s death, the Higley company cleared all the homes and trees on the Southtown block. Higley is now a creditor in the bankruptcy of Southtown; the company is owed almost $900,000. The empty Southtown block currently hosts a sign advertising the Higley company.

Thanks for your questions. I’ll answer more in future episodes.

In response to multiple Freedom of Information Act requests, the Ann Arbor police provided a lot of material. There are photographs of the home at 809 Henry Street. Written reports from four officers explain more. Footage from five body cameras is heavily redacted, but the recordings include time stamps from the day in question. The sequence of events is fairly clear.

Chelsey found Marge and called 911 at 5:03 p.m.

[Sirens sound effect]

Officer Davison arrived on the scene at 5:10. He ran upstairs and relieved Chelsey, who had been doing CPR on Marge. Officer Davison performed CPR for just over two minutes before paramedics arrived and took over. By 5:13, Officer Davison was headed downstairs to talk to Chelsey.

Davison’s bodycam footage is heavily redacted as he approaches the front door. The audio goes silent and large areas within the video are blurred. People appear as shadowy figures. Just outside the blurred areas, small clues remain: a clear view of someone’s hat or the edge of their face.

Heidi’s shadow is distinctive– hers is smaller and narrower than others.

The shadow of Heidi walked in the front door of 809 Henry Street before 5:14. Just after 5:14, the top of Heidi’s head is clearly visible, walking toward the living room. At 5:15, Heidi can be seen sitting down, throwing her feet up on an ottoman.

Officer Davison’s report from that night describes this quick timeline. He wrote:

[Sound effect- computer typing]

Once I was relieved from doing chest compressions, I [went] downstairs to interview Chelea. [sic] While speaking to Chelsea, Margaret's wife (Heidi Poscher) arrived on scene.

The second officer on the scene arrived less than a minute before Heidi. Officer Hoak walked in the front door and straight upstairs. He passed Officer Davison walking down the stairs.

[Room noise, equipment beeping]

As Heidi walked in the front door of 809 Henry Street, paramedics were still performing CPR on Marge.

That’s how quickly Heidi got there. She arrived three minutes after the first police officer, two minutes after paramedics, and moments after the second police officer.

Sergeant Anuskiewicz reached the scene a little after 5:30. At 5:42, he called detectives and explained the situation.

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
They own several businesses. And I think the coworker or the wife came here, found her wife, 67 year old female in the upstairs bedroom.

ELIZABETH NELSON:
HIs uncertainty about who found Marge makes sense– by the time he got there, both Chelsey and Heidi were there. The Sergeant recognized that the timeline was relevant. He questioned Chelsey about what happened.

[Bodycam recording]

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
You were the first one here?

CHELSEY SYKES:
I was the first one here, yes.

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
And why did you come here?

CHELSEY SYKES:
Heidi called me,

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
Pardon me?

CHELSEY SYKES:
Heidi, she called me. She wasn’t able to get ahold of Marge and I work over at Venue and she asked me if I’d walk over

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
Okay

CHELSEY SYKES:
So I grabbed my bags and I decided to drive instead.

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
Okay

CHELSEY SYKES:
There were cars parked in the street so I had to drive around and I turned around at Pioneer and I came back

SERGEANT ANUSKIEWICZ:
Where was she at?

CHELSEY SYKES:
I don’t know where she was.

ELIZABETH NELSON:
Officer Davison’s written report from that night includes Heidi’s explanation of where she was. From his report, quote:

[Sound effect- computer typing]

Heidi stated that she left the venue at about 10:00 AM today for a meeting in Cleveland, Ohio. Heidi last spoke to Margaret at about 12:00 PM and it was a pleasant conversation. Heidi's meeting ended at about 2:00 PM and Heidi began trying to contact Margaret by phone, but Margaret was not responding. Heidi called several times but there was no answer. This is very uncommon, so Heidi contacted Chelsea and asked that she go check on Margaret.

Nearly a week later, an Ann Arbor detective called Heidi to get more information. In a written report, Detective Luick explains the phone call she had with Heidi on October 16:

[Sound effect- computer typing]

HEIDI started by telling me the night before, she and MARGARET had a normal evening, and MARGARET did not seem out [of] character. HEIDI stated she and MARGARET ate dinner and then MARGARET read the New York Times. The two went to bed and woke up the next morning to start their day. HEIDI explained she had a meeting with a developer in Cleveland at noon, so she left Ann Arbor around 10am. HEIDI attended her meeting and left Cleveland at approximately 2:00 PM. HEIDI stated she began calling MARGARET after the meeting and could not reach her after several attempts. HEIDI explained this worried her because it was unlike MARGARET to not respond in a timely fashion especially knowing HEIDI would be out of her meeting.

HEIDI checked her phone logs and stated she called their employee, CHELSEY SYKES, to check on MARGARET at 4:53 PM. HEIDI stated she called CHELSEY because she knew she would be close by. HEIDI estimated that she was about an hour away, just driving into Michigan when she called CHELSIE.

[MUSIC]

This is the timeline that Heidi herself offered to the police. She told Detective Luick that she called Chelsey at 4:53. That time is consistent with when Chelsey arrived and called 911. Heidi told Detective Luick that she was an hour away when she made that phone call. That time is not consistent with when Heidi actually arrived on the scene. How did Heidi get there in twenty minutes if she was an hour away?

None of the written reports from that day include the time that Heidi arrived at the scene. In bodycam footage, Sergeant Anuskiewicz asked about Heidi’s location when she made that call to Chelsey. Detective Luick accepted Heidi’s answer that she was at the state line, an hour away.

Officer Davison filed his written report the same night that Marge was found. Sergeant Anuskiewicz and Detective Allen submitted reports the following day. Detective Luick submitted her report over a month later, on November 13th.

Detective Luick filed her report on the same day that Crain’s Detroit published the first story about Marge’s death. Luick’s report includes the most significant details that no one questioned: Heidi’s alibi, and her claim that she was an hour away when she called Chelsey.

[MUSIC]

At least three officers on the scene saw Heidi on Henry Street right away, but they didn’t write down the time. Did none of them see Detective Luick’s report? Did Officer Davison, Officer Hoak, or Sergeant Anuskiewicz ever see Heidi’s claim that she was an hour away?

Police could have identified where Heidi was when she made that call to Chelsey. Mobile carriers can track the cell phone towers Heidi’s phone would have used to make the call. Why didn’t they?

Cleveland is a big place. Detective Luick’s call to Gareth Vaughn didn’t confirm the location of the meeting. Did Heidi drive two hours for a meeting at noon? If the meeting ended at 2 p.m., why did it take Heidi over three hours to get back to Ann Arbor?

Detective Luick could have called the second person from that meeting in Cleveland. She could have asked for more details about where exactly the meeting took place. Why did it take so long for Detective Luick to file her report? How well did she remember her phone calls with Heidi and Gareth if she wrote them up nearly a month after they happened?

Thank you for listening. Visit HollowHype.com to find more information about this episode.

Coming up in episode 23: suicide notes include explanation that does not make sense. The circumstances are troubling and confusing to people who knew Marge.

If you have something to share about Heidi’s activities in Michigan, Ohio, West Virginia, or California or you have questions you’d like answered in a future episode, please reach out to hollowhypepodcast@gmail.com

“Where was she at?”
Broadcast by